Autocratic Legalism Kim Lane Scheppele Upd Jun 2026

Scheppele argues that legalistic autocrats follow a predictable "script" to hollow out liberal democracies from within:

Autocratic legalism sits in the treacherous space between them. It is, Scheppele writes, the use of liberal legal forms to achieve autocratic ends . The autocrat does not burn the constitution; he reinterprets it. He does not abolish parliament; he shrinks its quorum. He does not jail all opposition journalists; he passes a defamation law with such breathtakingly vague standards that only the government’s critics are charged. autocratic legalism kim lane scheppele upd

Electoral laws are often redesigned to favor the incumbent. Gerrymandering, changes to campaign finance, and the introduction of complex voting rules make it nearly impossible for a fractured opposition to win, even if they hold a majority of the popular vote. Why It Works He does not abolish parliament; he shrinks its quorum